Verse 16x1821aapaayaa


G4

1
neither is Asad cruelty-asking, nor is [your] tyranny madness-inclined
2
to the extent that I sought you, I found you {intimacy/affection}-testing

'Asking; — asker'.
'Inclining (to or towards, -kī t̤araf, or -par), leaning; inclined; propense, having a propensity, or inclination, or partiality (for); biassed; fond (of), taking delight (in), addicted (to)'.
'Familiarity, intimacy; attachment, affection, friendship'.

References
Arshi, Imtiyaz Ali Ghazal# 5
Raza, Kalidas Gupta 319
Nuskhah-e-Hamidiyah 32-35
Asi, Abdul Bari 53-54
Gyan Chand 67-70
Hamid Ali Khan Open Image

For background see S. R. Faruqi's choices . This verse is NOT one of his choices; I thought it was interesting and have added it myself. For more on Ghalib's unpublished verses, see the discussion in 4,8x . Why does the lover keep on seeking her out, at all costs, when the only result is more cruelty from the beloved? Why, when he keeps on humbly seeking her out, does she so constantly and viciously persecute him? Is he masochistic? Is she sadistic? Are they both insane? No, no, the first line assures us. Asad's behavior isn't 'cruelty-asking': he's not crazy, he's not looking for trouble. Nor is 'tyranny'-- her essential nature, her personified self-- 'madness-inclined': she's not crazy herself, and she's not attracted by craziness in others. So perhaps there's method in their madness? There's only one conclusion, one classic rationale-- the lover's last, desperate resort: 'It's really a compliment in disguise-- it's because she's testing me!' Testing opens at least a sliver of distant possibility that the lover might someday be accepted. Whereas the worst thing of all would be-- to be ignored. (For proof, see 119,1 .) For a genuinely brilliant exploration of the lover's rationale of 'testing', compare 4,4 . In any case, there's lovely internal rhyme in the first line, and the wordplay of 'searching' and 'finding' in the second line. Note for meter fans: In the first line, the twofold use of to replace is of course to accommodate the meter, by providing long syllables where these are required. graphics/seeking.jpg