Verse 11after 1847iirbhii thaa


G5

In this meter the first long syllable may be replaced by a short; and the next-to-last long syllable may be replaced by two shorts.


1
of Rekhtah , you are not the only Ustad , Ghalib
2
they say that in an earlier time/age there was even/also some Mir /'master'

'A master; craftsmaster, skilful man, adept, expert; preceptor, tutor, teacher; professor'.
'Time, period, duration; season; a long time; an age'.
'Chief, leader, master, head'.

References
Arshi, Imtiyaz Ali Ghazal# 41
Raza, Kalidas Gupta 397
Hamid Ali Khan Open Image

This is one of the few verses in the divan that are explicitly about Urdu poetry and its history. In a typically complex way, Ghalib pays tribute to Mir, the only other Ustad he depicts as worthy of comparison to himself. Implicitly but clearly, he relegates all other Urdu poets to something less than full mastery (or even consigns them to complete forgettability). Even toward Mir, his compliment is understated, to put it politely. Actually, it's more like backhanded. He locates Mir in the vaguest possible limbo: 'They say (but of course it's hard to tell about these rumors) that in an earlier age (when dinosaurs roamed the earth) there was some Mir (at least, that was said to be his name)'. Then of course 'Mir' is not only a pen-name , but also a word (see the definition above), so the reference might even be construed as applying to any (unnamed) great 'master' among Ghalib's predecessors. And we could also of course interpret the understated second line as ironic-- a tribute to Mir's radical well-knownness and immense prestige: 'They say that long ago there was somebody called Shakespeare...'. Actually, Mir's lifespan (1722-1810) overlapped a bit with Ghalib's (1797-1869), and Mir's poetry was unquestionably a most valuable source of ideas and techniques for him. However, Hali's anecdote above, in which Mir is said to have commented on Ghalib's very early poetry, is almost certainly apocryphal. (Although if Ghalib was in fact a couple of years older than he claimed to be, as Mehr Farooqi considers possible, it might open just the smallest window of opportunity.) Compare Ghalib's much more genuinely admiring tributes to Mir, in 92,7 and 92,8x . graphics/rekhtah.jpg