Verse 6x1816uusthaa


G1

1
the opening/expansion of the temperament extinguished/'rosed' the color of a 'whole-garden'
2
this bound/constrained heart was, so to speak, a peacock's egg

'Opening; expansion; dispersion, or vanishing (of sorrow, &c.); clearance (of clouds, &c.); —deliverance'.
'To extinguish (a candle or lamp)'.
'Bound; restrained; —referred back (to); related, connected (with), depending (on)'.

References
Arshi, Imtiyaz Ali Ghazal# 31
Raza, Kalidas Gupta 160
Nuskhah-e-Hamidiyah 83-84
Asi, Abdul Bari 71-72
Gyan Chand 116
Hamid Ali Khan Open Image

For background see S. R. Faruqi's choices . This verse is NOT one of his choices; I thought it was interesting and have added it myself. For more on Ghalib's unpublished verses, see the discussion in 4,8x . The idiomatic meaning of as 'to extinguish' a candle is entirely established. (See the definition above, and also think of Faiz: .) It comes directly from the inverted cup (or flower) shape of most candle-snuffers. Here's an example, from India, that includes a snuffer that conveniently hangs from the candlestick itself: graphics/candlesnuffer.jpg If we adopt this reading, then the 'opening' of the previously 'bound/constrained' temperament turned it into a comparative candle-snuffer, for the peacock who emerged from this metaphorical egg was (eventually!) so radiantly beautiful that his glory outshone and thus 'extinguished' (by comparison) the color of a whole garden. But Ghalib almost always uses such idiomatic expressions in both their colloquial and their dictionary meanings. On a literal reading, the peacock who emerged from the newly-hatched egg of the 'opened' temperament 'rosed' the color of the whole garden. That would suggest giving it a radiance, a brilliance, a roseate glory. Compare for example 15,4 , in which the of the rose turns the garden water-channel into a 'lamp-display'. Gyan Chand insists on as 'to reveal, to make manifest'. I don't know where exactly he gets it from, and life is too short to do every bit of peripheral research. You, dear reader, can decide for yourself. graphics/peacockegg.jpg